IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences

Print ISSN: 2581-9844

Online ISSN: 2456-9615

CODEN : IIJFA2

IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences (IJFMTS) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2016 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination of knowledge, we will be more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 875

PDF Downloaded: 496


Get Permission Patel and Parashar: Study of pattern of injuries sustained by two-wheeler drivers in a tertiary care hospital of Bhopal city


Introduction

According to a study conducted by the National Transportation Planning and Research Centre (NTPRC) every four minutes a person is killed or injured in road accidents in India1. The spectrum of injuries depends on site, direction & force of impact, design of vehicle, ejection of victim and supervening factors like overturning or fire.1

Road Traffic accidents (RTAs) have emerged as a major global public health problem of this century and are now recognised as “veritable neglected pandemic”.2 Motor vehicle crashes are a common cause of death, disability and demand for emergency medical care.2

Globally, about 1 million people die each year from traffic crashes and about 20-50 million are injured or permanently disabled. 3 In 2000, road traffic injuries were ranked as the ninth leading cause of death and the eighth leading cause of disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) lost globally by the Global Burden of Disease Study.4 Accidents, tragically, are not often due to ignorance, but are due to carelessness, thoughtlessness and over confidence.5

With increasing population, increasing vehicular density and meager infrastructure amenities, the 21st century is plagued by yet another important issue, Road Traffic Accidents (RTA) which has in fact become a slow modern pandemic and prescribing to a pattern of a secular trend of disease epidemiology.6 A majority of victims of road traffic injuries are men in the age group of 15-44 years and belong to the poorer sections of society.7 Also, a vast majority of those killed and injured are pedestrians, motorcyclists and pillions riders, and bicyclists.7

The magnitude of Road traffic accidents and fatalities in India is alarming. In 2009, 4.22 lakh road traffic accidents and 1.27 lakh road traffic fatalities were reported. These numbers translate into one road accident every minute and one road accident death every four minutes. However, this is an underestimate, as not all injuries are reported to the police.8

The main aim of the study is to study the pattern of injuries among two-wheeler drivers involved in road traffic accidents, in relation to different parameters in a Tertiary Care Hospital of Bhopal City.

Materials and Methods 

It is a prospective observational study carried out at a tertiary care hospital in Bhopal, during the one year period from 1st January 2017 to 31st December 2017.

Study population were two-wheeler drivers who came to emergency department of the hospital for treatment after sustaining injuries due to RTA.

Inclusion criteria

All victims of different age groups from 11 to 60 years of road traffic accidents who were driving two-wheeler brought to the study place directly after accident.

Exclusion criteria

Victims of less than 11 years and more than 60 years, pillion riders of two-wheeler, pedestrians or drivers/passengers of Four/Three wheelers, patients shifted from other hospitals.

Results

The total numbers of victim were 832 during the study period, among them 709 (85.21%) were male and 123 (14.78%) were female. Most of the victims were of younger age group (21- 30 years). The time of accident was evening (6 pm to 12 midnight) in the majority (43.62%) of cases. Most of the accidents (33.65%) have been taken place in rainy season (July to Sept.). In most of the cases (34.25%) the cause of accident was “Rash Driving”. The injury sustained in majority of cases was multiple injuries (37.86%) followed by head injury (29.32%). In majority of cases the victims who sustained different injuries were not wearing the helmet (79.68%). The duration of stay in hospital was 1 to 2 weeks in majority (44.95%) of cases. Partial recovery has been observed in 28.12% of cases while 67.06% of victims were completely recovered of their injuries. Deaths were observed in 4.80% of victims.

Table 1

Age and gender wise distribution

Age

Male (85.21%)

Female (14.78%)

Total

11- 20 years

222 (31.31%)

51 (41.46%)

273 (32.81%)

21- 30 years

302 (42.59%)

62 (50.40%)

364 (43.75%)

31- 40 years

113 (15.93%)

07 (5.69%)

120 (14.42%)

41- 50 years

38 (05.35%)

03 (2.43%)

41 (04.92%)

51- 60 years

34 (04.79%)

00 (00.00%)

34 (04.08%)

Total

709

123

832

Table 2

Time of Accident

Time

11-20 years

21-30 years

31-40 years

41-50 years

51-60 years

Total

Grand Total

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

06 am- 12 pm

38

18

85

19

33

02

08

00

11

00

175 (24.68%)

39 (31.70%)

214 (25.72%)

12- 06 pm

67

11

57

12

24

01

09

01

07

00

164 (23.13%)

25 (20.32%)

189 (22.71%)

06 pm- 12 am

98

22

133

29

44

04

18

02

13

00

306 (43.15%)

57 (46.34%)

363 (43.62%)

12 am- 06 am

19

00

27

02

12

00

3

00

03

00

64 (9.02%)

02 (1.62%)

66 (7.93%)

Total

222

51

302

62

113

07

38

03

34

00

709

123

832

Table 3

Seasonal Variations

Month

11- 20 years

21- 30 years

31- 40 years

41- 50 years

51- 60 years

Total

Grand Total

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

Jan.- March

38

13

71

17

26

02

06

01

09

00

150 (21.15%)

33 (26.82%)

183 (21.99%)

Apr.- June

47

04

65

11

22

01

12

00

07

00

153 (21.57%)

16 (13.00%)

169 (20.31%)

July- Sept.

83

19

94

19

37

03

11

02

12

00

237 (33.42%

43 (34.95%)

280 (33.65%)

Oct.- Dec.

54

15

72

15

28

01

09

00

06

00

169 (23.83%)

31 (25.20%)

200 (24.03%)

Total

222

51

302

62

113

07

38

03

34

00

709

123

832

Table 4

Causes of Accident

Cause

11- 20 yrs.

21- 30 yrs.

31- 40 yrs.

41- 50 yrs.

51- 60 yrs.

Total

Grand Total

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

M

F

Rash Driving

103

09

114

20

31

00

08

00

00

00

256 (36.10%)

29 (23.57%)

285 (34.25%)

Wrong Signal Crossing

78

04

88

05

45

02

11

00

03

00

225 (31.73%)

11 (8.94%)

236 (28.36%)

Alcohol

07

00

51

01

23

00

06

00

04

00

91 (12.83%)

01 (0.81%)

92 (11.05%)

Other

34

38

49

36

14

05

13

03

27

00

137 (19.32%)

82 (66.66%)

219 (26.32%)

Total

222

51

302

62

113

07

38

03

34

00

709

123

832

Table 5

Type of Injuries Sustained by Victims

Injuries

With Helmet

Without Helmet

Total

Head Injuries

16 (6.55%)

228 (93.44%)

244 (29.32%)

Limb Injuries

27 (15.42%)

148 (84.57%)

175 (21.03%)

Chest Injuries

13 (24.07%)

41 (75.92%)

54 (6.49%)

Abdominal Injuries

03 (9.67%)

28 (90.32%)

31 (3.72%)

Spinal Injuries

05 (38.46%)

08 (61.53%)

13 (1.56%)

Multiple Injuries

105 (33.33%)

210 (66.66%)

315 (37.86%)

Total

169 (20.31%)

663 (79.68%)

832 (100%)

Table 6

Duration of Stay in Hospital-

Injury

Stay

<24 Hours

1 day to 1 week

1 to 2 weeks

2 weeks to 1 month

>1 Month

Total

Head Injury

05 (2.04%)

49 (20.08%)

81 (33.19%)

96 (39.34%)

13 (5.32%)

244 (29.32%)

Limb Injury

12 (6.85%)

78 (44.57%)

45 (25.71%)

32 (18.28%)

08 (4.57%)

175 (21.03%)

Chest Injury

03 (5.55%)

16 (29.62%)

22 (40.74%)

11 (20.37%)

02 (3.70%)

54 (6.49%)

Abdominal Injury

00 (00%)

04 (12.90%)

09 (29.03%)

17 (54.83%)

01 (3.22%)

31 (3.72%)

Spinal Injury

00 (00%)

00 (00%)

02 (15.38%)

08 (61.53%)

03 (23.07%)

13 (1.56%)

Multiple Injuries

07 (2.22%)

71 (22.53%)

215 (68.25%)

19 (6.03%)

03 (0.95%)

315 (37.86%)

Total

27 (3.24%)

218 (26.20%)

374 (44.95%)

183 (21.99%)

30 (3.61%)

832

Table 7

Outcome of Different Injuries

Injury

Outcome

Death

Partial Recovery

Complete Recovery

Total

Head Injury

14 (5.73%)

51 (20.90%)

179 (73.36%)

244 (29.32%)

Limb Injury

01 (0.57%)

131 (74.85%)

43 (24.57%)

175 (21.03%)

Chest Injury

03 (5.55%)

09 (16.66%)

42 (77.77%)

54 (6.49%)

Abdominal Injury

01 (3.22%)

03 (9.67%)

27 (87.09%)

31 (3.72%)

Spinal Injury

00 (00%)

05 (38.46%)

08 (61.53%)

13 (1.56%)

Multiple Injuries

21 (6.66%)

35 (11.11%)

259 (82.22%)

315 (37.86%)

Total

40 (4.80%)

234 (28.12%)

558 (67.06%)

832

Discussion

RTA is a major preventable cause of mortality and morbidity in India. The 2-wheeler drivers are 2nd most common group affected, preceded only by pedestrians. They are more prone owing to inherent instability of the vehicle, poor roads, rash & negligent driving, non-usage of helmets & with recent frequent fuel hikes people prefer to use a 2-wheeler as much as possible.

In the present study the maximum victims were found to be male (85.21% of total 832 cases) as in case of studies by Saumil P. Merchant et al 1 (86.3%), Dandona R and Mishra A 2 (>80%), Nilambar Jha et al 5 (83%) Dr. E. Ravi Kiran et al 6 (85.71%), Abhishek Singh et al 8 (88.71%), Dileep Kumar R. et al 9 (87%), Rakesh Kakkar et al 10 (80.5%), and Harnam Singh & A.D. Aggaewal 11 (83.1%).

The age group most commonly affected in present study was 21 to 30 years (43.75%), possibly due to greater exposure of males of younger age group to outdoor activities and also due to ignorance of traffic rules and safety measures, similar results were found in studies by Nilambar Jha et al5 (31.3%), Dr. E. Ravi Kiran et al6 (25.5%) and Dileep Kumar R. et al. 9 The commonest age group affected was 13-16 years (30.5%) in the study by Harnam Singh and A.D. Aggarwal.11

The time of accident was in evening hours (from 6 pm to 12 midnight) in maximum number (43.62%) of cases, due to high traffic load on roads in evening hours similar to studies by Dr. E. Ravi Kiran et al 6 (33.5%) and Abhishek Singh et al.8

Maximum number of accidents (33.65%) were found in rainy season (July to September) probably due to slippery roads, as also found in study by E. Ravi Kiran et al 6 but according to study by Saumil P. Merchanr 1 and Harnam Singh & A.D. Aggarwal 11 maximum cases of RTA were found in summer (40.3%) and winter (54.2%) respectively.

Among various factors responsible for road traffic accidents, in present study most common cause (34.25%) of RTA was rash driving as in case of study by Rakesh Kakkar et al,10 alcohol was the cause of accident in only 11.05% of cases in present study; almost similar results (13%) was found in the study by E. Ravi Kiran et al.6 Alcohol impairs judgment, increases reaction time and diminishes visual acuity, hence increasing chances of an accident.

Multiple injuries were sustained in maximum (37.86%) number of cases. The duration of stay in hospital was 1 to 2 weeks in maximum number (44.95%) of cases. Although survival rate has been improved in the recent times due to availability of emergency treatment but still the mortality is very high. Along with it, there is a high rate of morbidity, leading to very poor quality of life in the survivors due to the devastating consequences.

Complete recovery was observed in maximum number (67.06%) of cases. 4.80% of cases proved to be fatal. Partial recovery has been observed in 28.12% of cases. Even in these cases there is loss of productive capacity of a family along with decrease in quality of life.

Conclusion

The incidence of RTA is rising, especially involving two-wheelers leading to loss of productive and young lives of Country. It is very common to consume alcohol, lack of protective measures, reckless driving etc. especially in younger generation. Keeping all these factors in mind some steps should be taken to formulate policies with a view of reducing mortality & morbidity due to RTA.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

P Saumil Merchant C Rohit Tapan Zariwala Ravindra Mehta Bhise Epidemiology of road traffic accidents (RTA) victims in Ahmedabad; A study of 5 years (1995-1999)J Indian Acad Forensic Med20093113742

2 

R Dandona A Mishra Deaths due to road traffic crashes in Hyderabad city in India: Need for strengthening surveillanceNatl Med J India200417749

3 

Krug E Injury: A leading cause of the global burden of disease. Geneva:WorldHealth Organization1999

4 

C J L Murray A D Lopez Alternative projections of mortality and disability by cause 1990–2020: Global Burden of Disease StudyLancet19973491498504

5 

N Jha D K Srinivasa G Roy S Jagdish Epidemiological Study of Road Traffic Accident Cases; A Study from South IndiaIndian J Comm Med2004XXIX1

6 

E R Kiran K M Saralaya K. Vijaya Prospective Study on Road Traffic AccidentsJPAFMAT20044

7 

G Gururaj Road traffic deaths, injuries and disabilities in India; Current scenarioNational Med J India2008211

8 

A Singh A Bhardwaj R Pathak S K Ahluwalia An Epidemiological Study of Road Traffic Accident Cases at a Tertiary Care Hospital in Rural HaryanaIndian J Comm Health2011232

9 

D R Kumar G M Raju Deaths due to Fatal Road Traffic Accidents; A Retrospective StudyJ Indian Acad Forensic Med2013353

10 

R Kakkar P Aggarwal Road Traffic Accident; Retrospective StudyIndian J Sci Res2014515962

11 

H Singh A D Aggarwal Fatal Road Traffic Accidents among Young ChildrenJ Indian Acad Forensic Med2010324



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Original Article


Article page

95-98


Authors Details

Brinda Patel, Ranjan Parashar


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files