IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences

Print ISSN: 2581-9844

Online ISSN: 2456-9615

CODEN : IIJFA2

IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences (IJFMTS) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2016 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination of knowledge, we will be more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 174

PDF Downloaded: 150


Get Permission Wathore, Harbade, Zine, and Zine: Profile of bomb blast injuries


Introduction

Bomb blast injuries in India have unfortunately been a recurring and tragic reality, stemming from acts of terrorism and insurgency that have targeted various regions of the country. These incidents have resulted in significant loss of life, severe injuries, and lasting trauma for those affected. The impact of bomb blast injuries in India is not only physical but also psychological, affecting individuals, families, and communities at large.1, 2, 3, 4, 5

The injuries sustained in bomb blasts can vary in severity and type, depending on factors such as the type of explosive device used, the location of the blast, and the proximity of individuals to the explosion. Common injuries include shrapnel wounds, burns, fractures, traumatic amputations, and head injuries. The force of the blast can cause extensive damage to internal organs, leading to conditions such as blast lung injury, abdominal trauma, and hearing loss.

Immediate medical attention is crucial in treating bomb blast injuries, as timely intervention can help save lives and prevent further complications. Emergency responders and healthcare professionals play a vital role in providing triage, stabilization.

Specialized care to those injured in bomb blasts. The coordination of resources, including medical supplies, personnel, and transportation, is essential in managing mass casualty incidents resulting from bomb blasts.6, 7, 8, 9

In addition to the physical injuries, bomb blast survivors may also experience long-term psychological effects, such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, and depression. Mental health support and counseling services are crucial in helping individuals cope with the emotional aftermath of such traumatic events and rebuild their lives.

Preventive measures are key in addressing the threat of bomb blasts in India, including enhancing security measures, intelligence gathering, and public awareness campaigns. Collaboration between government agencies, law enforcement, and the community is essential in preventing and responding to acts of terrorism and minimizing the impact of bomb blast injuries.

Despite the challenges posed by bomb blast injuries in India, resilience, solidarity, and a commitment to peace and security can help communities heal and rebuild in the aftermath of such tragic events. By working together to address the root causes of terrorism, strengthen emergency response capabilities, and provide comprehensive support to survivors, we can strive towards a safer and more secure future for all.10, 11

Types of injuries

The injuries sustained in bomb blasts can be categorized into primary, secondary, tertiary, and quaternary injuries.7 Primary injuries are caused by the direct effects of the blast wave on the body, leading to injuries such as blast lung, eardrum rupture, and internal organ damage. Secondary injuries result from flying debris and shrapnel, causing penetrating wounds and lacerations. Tertiary injuries occur when individuals are thrown by the blast force, leading to fractures, head injuries, and blunt trauma. Quaternary injuries encompass all other injuries; including burns, crush injuries, and psychological trauma.

Patterns of injuries

The patterns of injuries in bomb blasts often follow distinct trends based on the type of explosion, the distance from the blast site, and the surrounding environment. For example, individuals closer to the epicentre of the blast are more likely to sustain primary injuries, while those further away may experience secondary and tertiary injuries from debris and structural collapse. The presence of protective barriers or structures can also influence the distribution of injuries, with individuals behind cover being shielded from the direct effects of the blast wave.

Medical response

In responding to bomb blast incidents, medical professionals must be prepared to address a wide range of injuries and prioritize care based on the severity and type of injuries sustained. Immediate interventions may include airway management, haemorrhage control, and stabilization of critical injuries. 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17 Trauma centres and hospitals must be equipped to handle mass casualty incidents and provide comprehensive care to a large number of patients in a short period of time.

Table 1

Bomb blasts in Mumbai 7

Year

Date

Place

Vehicle Used

Death

Injured

1993

12th March

Nariman Point To Bandra

Scooter

257

700

1993

29th October

Matunga Road

Train

Nil

11

1998

27th February

Santacruz, Kandivalli, Virar

Train

04

Nil

2002

2nd December

Ghatkopar rly. station

Best bus

02

38

2002

06th December

McDonald hotel

AC duct

nil

25

2003

27th January

Ville parle

bicycle

01

30

2003

13th march

Muland station

Local train

11

66

2003

28th July

Ghatkopar

Best bus

04

35

2003

25th Augest

Gate way of india and new Zaveri Bazzar

Taxi

25

178

2004

3rd March

Virar

Not Known

01

03

The following study is carried out with keeping in mind following aims and objectives:-The pattern of injuries due to bomb blast on the victim. Identification of the dead body of the deceased victims. To ascertain the distance of the victims from the device/blast from nature of injuries. Eardrum injuries sustained and mental trauma to live victims. To ascertain the presence of foreign bodies, primary and secondary missiles and thereby assisting in investigations. To know the cause of deaths of such cases. To facilitate the collection of evidentiary materials for chemical analysis and identity purpose. To pinpoint, highlight the lacunas in existing crisis management system to improve further management system and immediate steps to be taken for blast victims and mass casualties in casualty and mortuary services in public hospitals.

Material and Methods

The present study “The Profile of Bomb Blast Injuries’’ has been carried out in the one of the Major Medical College and Hospital in Maharashtra State. The present study has been carried out during the period of January 2003 to July 2004,

During this study total cases studied were sixty nine (69), they are grouped as A & B.

A: - 32 cases died due to bomb blast has been meticulously studied.

B: - 37 injured persons (clinical cases) due to bomb blast has been studied in the different wards of hospital.

Two proforma used to carry out the present study the deaths in bomb blast cases and injured in bomb blast cases. Analysis was done from tables used to study for approximate distance from blast site in feets, action of the victim at the time of blast, position of the victim related to blast site, level of consciousness following blast, Perforation of ear, Mental condition of the victim during admission, follow up after every 24 hrs and at the time of discharge, Condition at the time of discharge.

Results

The observations are described in the following tables and graphs.

Table 2

A; showing age wise distribution of the victim died due to bomb blast. (Gr. A)

Sr. no.

Age group in years

No. Of cases

Percantage of cases

1

0 TO 10

0

0

2

11 TO 20

9

24.32

3

21 TO 30

14

37.83

4

31 TO 40

7

18.9

5

41 TO 50

4

10.8

6

51 TO 60

2

5.45

7

Above 60

1

2.7

Total

37

100

Table 3

Showing the sex wise distribution of the victims died in bomb blast (Gr A)

Sex

No. Of cases

Percentage of cases

Male

32

86.48

Female

5

13.52

Total

37

100

Table 4

Showing the number of deaths in regard to religion. (Gr. A)

Religion

No.of cases

Percentage of cases

Hindu

30

81.09

Muslim

7

18.91

Total

37

100

Table 5

Showingthe residential jurisdiction of victim died in bomb blast. (Gr. A)

Residential jurisidiction

No. of cases

Percentage

Within mumbai city

25

78.13

Outside mumbai but within state

3

9.37

Outside the state

3

9.37

Noy known

1

3.13

Total

32

100

Table 6

Showing distrubtion of nature of injuries found over the bodies

Nature of injuries

No. of cases in area of hnf

No. of cases in area of upper limbs

No. of cases in area of lower limbs

No. of cases in area of chest

No. of cases in area of abdomen

No. of cases in area of back

Burns

23

23

18

14

11

15

Lacerations

21

20

24

4

9

6

Contusions

24

25

31

12

14

13

Abrasion

25

25

31

14

17

13

Punctures

15

20

18

14

13

7

Degloving

4

6

12

1

0

5

Fractures

14

10

12

4

Nil

3

Perforations

Nil

Nil

Nil

Nil

5

Nil

Amputations

1

1

1(left leg)

1

Nil

1

No injuries

1

2

10

10

7

12

B: 1 Showing age wise distribution of injured persons due to bomb blast. (Gr. B)

1

0 TO 10

0

0

2

11 TO 20

9

24.32

3

21 TO 30

14

37.83

4

31 TO 40

7

18.9

5

41 TO 50

4

10.8

6

51 TO 60

2

5.45

7

ABOVE 60

1

2.7

Total

37

100

Table B 2: Showing sex wise distribution of the injured patients. (Gr. B).

Sex

No. of cases

Percentage of cases

Male

32

86.48

Female

5

13.52

Total

37

100

B 3: Showing religion wise distribution of the injured of bomb blast. (Gr. B)

Religion

No.of cases

Percentage of cases

Hindu

30

81.09

Muslim

7

18.91

Total

37

100

B 4: Showing the approximate distance of 115 persons from the blast site. (Gr. B).

Distance in feet

No. Of cases injured

Percentage of cases

5

4

10.81

10

7

18.9

15

4

10.81

20

5

13.5

25

3

8.1

30

4

10.81

40

4

10.81

50

2

5.45

B 5: Showing the incidences of ear perforation in total admitted bomb blast victims. (Gr.B)

Perforation

No. Of cases

Percentage of cases

Bilateral ear perforation

9

24.32

Unilateral ear perforation

5

13.51

Unilateral perforation with csom in other ear

3

8.12

No perforation

20

54.05

Total

37

100

B 6: Showing action motion movement of the victim of bomb blast at the time of incidence. (Gr. B).

Action of victims

No. Of cases

Percentage of cases

Walking

19

51.35

Sitting

4

10.81

Standing

11

29.72

Working

3

8.02

Total

37

100

B 7: showing the incidences of post traumatic stress disease (PTSD) in the persons injured from bomb blast. (Gr. B).

Type of stress

No. Of cases

Percentage of cases

Victims with ptsd

25

67.56

Victims without ptsd

12

32.44

Total

37

100

B 8: showing the nature of external injuries found in the injured admitted cases (Gr. B).

No. Of cases in area of hnf

No. Of cases in area of upper limbs

No. Of cases in area of lower limbs

No. Of cases in area of chest

No. Of cases in area of abdomen

No. Of cases in area of back

8

6

10

3

3

6

8

10

19

3

4

4

15

27

28

10

7

10

12

24

26

5

6

6

9

17

20

5

6

5

NIL

3

5

NIL

NIL

NIL

NIL

3

3

NIL

NIL

NIL

3

1

14

NIL

NIL

4

17

9

2

26

28

24

B 9: Showing the incidence of sudden unconsciousness in total admitted bomb blast victims (Gr. B).

Consciousness

No. of cases

Percentage of cases

Sudden unconsciousness

16

43.25

Normal

21

56.75

Total

37

100

Discussion

The present study“ The Profile of Bomb Bilast ”has been carried out in one of the Major Medical College and Hospital in Maharashtra State. The present study has been carried out during the period of January 2003 t0 July 2004. In the present work total cases were studied were 69.

They are grouped as under:

A:- 32 cases brought dead in the hospital died due to bomb blast.

B:- 37 cases (clinical) injured due to Bomb blast admitted in the hospital.

Statistic was not applied, There is paucity of identical study data in the literature for comparison of our findings.

Age wise distribution of cases were studied and it was found that maximum number of cases i.e. 21 cases (65.62%) were found in the age group 11 to 40 years in group A. (Table A 1) In group B maximum number of cases i.e. 30 cases (81.06%) were in the age group 11 to 40 years (Table B1).

The probable reason for maximum cases in those particular age groups can be given as the persons in these age groups were the working and roaming population and are exposed more 1o exterior world as compared to the age groups below 10 yrs and after 41 yrs of life.

As shown in table A2 and B 2 the sex wise distribution, the percentage of males outnumbers the females in both groups, the brought dead and clinical cases i.e. 90.62 % and 86.48 % respectively. The reason of their higher distribution was due to prevailing culture of male dominance in productivity in the Indian society. Male were working members so they are more exposed to outside world whereas females are more engaged in household activities.

When the data was subjected to the religion wise distribution of the cases it was found that the percentage of Hindus were 84.37 % ( as per table A-3) in the dead cases, and 81.06 % in the injured cases (as per Table B3) respectively. The probable reason behind this might be due to the reason as the population and density of Hindus in Mumbai and nearby vicinity was more as compared to Muslims.

When the data is critically analyzed for the persons died in bomb blast for their regional (residential) distribution. It was found that the person from within Mumbai were much more as compare to Outsiders 78.12%, (Table A-4). The probable reason was due to both incidences taken into study have been occurred in Mumbai and area where it is occurred , one of it is a crowded market place and other Place is a popular historical monument, where the local residents usually visits more in numbers than the outsiders.

When the data critically analyzed for the injuries sustained in both groups, dead bodies as well as injured clinical cases as in table A 5 and B-8 respectively, it was observed that the injuries like burns, abrasions, contusions, lacerations were abundant in numbers over the major area of body. The perforation of cavities like abdomen seen in many cases in dead. The fractures and degloving injuries were found in decreasing order.

It was observed that the persons who are closed to the blast sites were sustained injuries like degloving and fractures and amputation and in some cases total distortion and fragmentation of body occurs. The abrasions, contusions, lacerations and Punctures were mainly due to the fragments generated during blast and the secondary missiles generated during blast. Burns were almost due the dual effect i.e. the heat generated during blast and secondary fire asthe fire caught by inanimate objects and various vehicles and objects carrying inflammable material like taxi containing petrochemicals in the nearby vicinity.

In the present study the data related to identity was some meticulously collected and dispersed via different agencies like police, media and local booths formed at postmortem centers that all the dead bodies has been identified and claimed by relatives funeral purpose.

In the present study when the samples collected were analyzed for explosive material, chemical analysis reports reveals that Nitrite (post explosion residue) was present in all samples. Nitrite was the basic component of many of the explosives used recently. While collecting the data through history some interesting cases has been uncovered which explains the various effects and modes of actions of the explosives.

One injured victim narrated the history that he was around 5feet away from the site of explosion. At the time of explosion he experienced electrocution (sudden vibration and numbness) like Sensation. This may be due to the different energy waves and radiation generated during blast.

In other incidence one victim experienced a sudden fall at time of blast and after few seconds she pushed up to the distance of 5 feet towards the direction of blast. This explains the positive and negative pressure waves generated during blast. 18, 19, 20, 21

One injured seen that one person who is sitting with the wall behind him has been blown upwards up to the height of 10 feet's after explosion. This explains the resistance offered by wall to the positive pressure generated during blast and is transformed into the victim sitting close to it.

Many people who witnessed the blast experienced that they are immediately thrown away opposite to the direction of the blast while few others experienced that they were sucked towards blast site. This explains the positive and negative waves generated during blast.

During postmortem examination a spanner has been removed from one dead body. This spanner is blown as a secondary missile from the taxi found in the blast.

After blast local peoples, social workers, local vehicles, ambulance squads from different social and governmental organizations, police vehicles all rushed towards the incidence sites. All have contributed in the fast transportation of victims and dead bodies towards various nearest hospitals and institutes. But there was no co-ordination between all these agencies which created hawking atmosphere resulting in the unnecessary delay in the treatment and Proper management of the situation medically. Mumbai peoples tolerate this panic very bravely and courageously without creating any problem to law and order of the city.

Compensation for victims kin: State (Government has announced financial assistance of Rs. 2 lakhs to next of kin of those who dies in blast. A spokesperson from Chief Minister’s office said families of seriously injured will receive Rs. 50000/-(T.O.I 27th Aug. 2003).

This endeavor is not to summarize the horrible experiences experienced by victims and till continue by the family members who have lost their beloved for forever but to fill the gap of knowledge and its application, by which such panic should be avoided. The overall management to be reviewed to decrease death toll, and effective medical and medico-legal management should be provided by studying different type of injuries sustained. Social, mental and spiritual trauma to the victims reviewed and their further rehabilitations considered.22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29

Conclusion

In the present work total 69 cases were studied by group A & B i.e group A: 32 cases brought dead in the hospital, while group B 17 cases admitted in the hospital and following conclusion are derived:-

Maximum affected persons from group A: deaths as well as from group B: clinical cases injured in bomb blast, were in the age group of 11 to 40 years. Maximum cases from group A (brought dead to the hospital) as well as clinical cases from group B admitted in the hospital are much higher in males as compared to females. The persons died, group A and injured cases (clinical) group B, during bomb blast in present study was mainly belong to Hindu religion as compared to other religions.It was found in the present study that the persons died m the bomb blast were mostly the residents of Mumbai city In comparison with those who are residing outside of Mumbai. The pattern of injuries found in brought dead (Group A) cases were mostly of burns, abrasions contusion, lacerations, while 1n few cases fractures, degloving injuries, amputations and total disruption of body was observed. The pattern of injuries found in injured (clinical) cases (Group B), were mostly of Abrasion, Contusion, Laceration & Burns. Maximum numbers of cases found injured (clinical) group B were within the range of 30 feet from the blast site. Bilateral perforation of ear was in more cases than the unilateral perforation of ear in the present study.(Group B). Mental trauma (post traumatic stress disease) was seen in majority injured cases.(Group B). Sudden unconsciousness was experienced by many injured victims of bomb blast in the present study.(43.24%) (Group B) Shock and Hemorrhage due to polytrauma was the cause of death in majority of cases. While in few cases it was associated with extensive burns, fatal head injury and burst abdomen. “Nitrite” was the basic chemical compound of explosive material traced in the chemical analysis in the present study.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

A Peter Noise and the Ear, Adult Audiology26th2012117

2 

N Apurba Principals of Forensic Medicine2nd20002602

3 

Bailley Love Short practice of surgery200028790

4 

PK Basu Ballistics and the Surgeons, Recent Advances In surgery by Roshanlal Gupta20232119

5 

A Besson F Saegesser Atlas of Chest Trauma and Associated Injuries119823525

6 

MP Chaudhary Information from Police Dept Times of India, dated20031

7 

GJ Cooper RL Maynard NL Cross JF Hill Casualties from terrorists bombingJ Trauma1983231195567

8 

EB Davis CE Rollins GD Reiber RM Anthony Suicide by pipe bomb: Acase reportAm J Forensic Med Pathol19992010414652

9 

KT Evans B Knight DK Whittalcer Forensic Radiology198199113

10 

N Saravanapavananthan Injuries caused by home-made explosivesForensic Sci Int19781221316

11 

KK Gandhe RN Saxena Law and principal of forensic ballistics4th1991328

12 

O Gmaton The Forensic Ballistics | Aboratory Forensic Medicine119775378

14 

G Keith Simpson’s101991146

15 

AG Kerr JET Byrne Conclusive effects of bomb blast on the earJ Laryngol Otol1975891123564

16 

B Knight Death from Explosion, Forensic Pathology19962703

17 

W Larence Erven, Emergency RescueGlencve Publishing Company, Inc.: CAUSA198043652

18 

TK Marshall Death from Explosive DeviceMed Sci Law1976162359

19 

TK Marshall Explosion Injuries, Injury by Firearms, Bombs and Explosives197661234

20 

TK Marshall The investigation of bombing. Legal Medicine Annual 1978.2.Marshall T K., A Pathologist’s view of terrorist violenceForensic Sci Int1988365767

21 

TK Marshall P‘agc 1 RS. Violence and Civil Disturbance, Pathology of Trauma, Mason24th1993

22 

A Oppenheim M Reuven G Yoram Blast lung injury from an explosionon a civilian bus, Look Smart Article199912

23 

J Rajs B Moberg JE Olsson Explosion related deaths in Sweden @ A forensic pathologic and Criminalistic StudyForensic Sci Int1987343596401

24 

KS Reddy Narayan Essentials of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology20001979

25 

LBE Shields M Donna JC Hunsaker Hunsaker, and Karl A Humbeit, non-terrorist suicidal deaths involving explosivesAm J Forensic Med Pathol20032410713

26 

ME Sigman CY Ma Detection limits for GC/MS analysis of organic explosivesJ Forensic Sci20014611210925

27 

LM Simons Weapons of mass destructionNat Geographic2002202235

28 

D Vitty RA Hall Investigation of Bomb and Explosives, Injury by Fire-Arms, Bombs and Explosives, Forensic Medicine1977

29 

C Walker H Cullum R Hiley An environmental survey relating 10 improvised ~ and immulsion /gel explosivesJ Forensic Sci20012547



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Original Article


Article page

37-45


Authors Details

Sanjay Wathore, Arvind Ranganthrao Harbade, Kanchan Kailash Zine, Kailash U. Zine


Article History

Received : 09-04-2024

Accepted : 22-04-2024


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files