IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences

Print ISSN: 2581-9844

Online ISSN: 2456-9615

CODEN : IIJFA2

IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences (IJFMTS) open access, peer-reviewed quarterly journal publishing since 2016 and is published under the Khyati Education and Research Foundation (KERF), is registered as a non-profit society (under the society registration act, 1860), Government of India with the vision of various accredited vocational courses in healthcare, education, paramedical, yoga, publication, teaching and research activity, with the aim of faster and better dissemination of knowledge, we will be more...

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article statistics

Viewed: 12

PDF Downloaded: 8


Get Permission Devchand, Krishnajaneyulu, Babu, Muralidhar, and Sushma: A prospective analysis of organophopshorous posioning at a Tertiary Care Hospital Vijaywada


Introduction

Organo phosphorus compound, a common pesticide used in agriculture for crop protection and pest control, is often implicated in accidental and suicidal poisoning in India. 1 It’s extensive use and easy accessibility has increased the chances of poisoning with these compounds.

It is a common toxicological emergency and acts by inhibiting the enzyme cholinesterase, results in accumulation of acetylcholine at synapses and myoneural junction leading to cholinergic over activity and is encountered in the Vijayawada. It is mainly familiar among the rural agricultural workers which include a substantial group of the population of this region.

As per WHO estimation that approximately 3 million pesticide poisoning occurs worldwide and cause more than 2,20,0000 deaths annually. Developing countries like India and Sri Lanka report alarming rates of toxicity and death. Suicidal poisoning with Organophosphorus compound is seen with increased frequency and carries 4-30% mortality in Indian studies. The common clinical presentations experienced by patients are Nausea and vomiting, Abdominal pain, Muscle twitching and Respiratory distress and based on the severity the treatment outcomes vary that includes Atropine, Pralidoxime, Mechanical Ventilation. Respiratory failure is a common complication of Organo phosphorus poisoning which is responsible for a high mortality, so timely effective treatment is crucial for survival. Recovery rate is higher if treated early on time and Mortality rates are less based on the type and quantity of OP poison consumed.

In India OP Poisoning remains one of the medical emergency admissions in hospital. 2

The demographic profile, the geographical terrain and the distribution of health care facilities is quite different in Vijayawada as compared to other region of the country. 3, 4 Despite the known dangers, there is a limited prospective data on the epidemiology and clinical outcomes of OP Poisoning in this area. Since there is a paucity of Literature regarding Organophosphorus compound poisoning in Vijayawada, this particular observational study was undertaken.

Aim

The Present study aims to fill the gap by providing a detailed analysis of OP Poisoning cases at tertiary care hospital in Vijayawada.

Objectives

To Determine the Prevalence of OP Poisoning among patients admitted in tertiary care hospital in Vijayawada

To analyse demographic characteristics and evaluate the clinical presentations and outcomes of patients with OP Poisoning.

Materials and Methods

  1. Study Sample: A total 75 cases of Organophosphorus compound poisoning were analysed. Clinical course of the cases was monitored and documented.

  2. Study Period: The present study was conducted for a period of 1 Year March 2022 to February 2023

  3. Study Settings: This study was conducted in Government General Hospital as well as tertiary care hospital Vijayawada.

  4. Study design: This is A prospective observational study

Inclusion criteria

Patients between the age groups of 10-70 years are who have consumed poison are who are willing to participate and ready to give consent were included in study.

Exclusion criteria

Patients above 70 years and who did not consume op poisoning and who are not willing to participate and refusing to give consent were excluded.

Study procedure

The data was collected from all poisoning cases admitted through emergency or Causality department, within 24 hours of exposure and in a detailed proforma as per the history given by patient / patient representative with particular importance being given to demographic details of the patient like age, sex, socio economic status, occupation, intention of poisoning, type of compound and its quantity consumed, place from referral and final outcome. All data were analysed, documented and interpretated as per the laid down protocol.

Statistical analysis

The data were analysed using Microsoft excel and Prism Graph pad.

Results

Table 1

Demographic & socio-economic profile of patients (N=75)

Age in years

Number

Percentage

10- 20

11

14.6%

20-30

40

53.3%

30-40

12

16%

40-50

8

10.6%

50-60

3

4%

Above 60

2

2.6%

Total

75

100

Sex

Number

Percentage

Male

43

57.3%

Female

32

42.6%

Total

75

100

Educational status

Number

Percentage

Illiterates

39

52%

Up to High school

22

29.3%

Up to Intermediate

10

13.3%

Up to Graduation

3

4%

Occupation

Number

Percentage

Agricultural workers

36

48%

House wives

17

22.6%

Labourers

12

16%

Students

7

9.3%

Others

3

4%

Total

75

100

Socio-economic status

Number

Percentage

Lower class

42

56%

Middle class

23

30.6%

Upper class

10

13.3%

Residence

Number

Percentage

Rural

57

76%

Urban

18

24%

Total

75

100

Table 2

Intention of poisoning (N=75)

Manner

Number (Male)

Percentage

Number (Female)

Percentage

Suicidal

29

38.6%

23

30.6%

Accidental

11

14.6%

8

10.6%

Homicidal

3

4%

1

1.3%

Total

43

57.2%

32

42.5%

Table 3

Types of poison consumed (N= 75)

Type of poison

Number

Cases%

Dichlorvos

38

50.6%

Methyl parathion

18

24%

Malathion

13

17.3%

Others

6

8%

Total

75

100

Table 4

Reason and outcome for consuming poisoning (N=75)

Reason

Number

Percentage

Financial

43

57.3%

Domestic

24

32%

Unspecified

8

10.6%

Total

75

100

Outcome

Number

Percentage

Survived

62

82.6%

Expired

13

17.3%

Total

75

100

Results

A total 75 cases of Organophosphorus compound poisoning were registered during the study period, March 2022 to February 2023. The age of patients varied from 1- 70 years.

The majority of patients, according to gender distribution were male (57.3 %) between the age group of 21-30 years. Persons of lower socio-economic status and lower middle class were the commonest patients (56%) and (30.6%) respectively. Most of the patients were either illiterate (52%) or educated up to high school (29.33%) and mainly belonging to rural areas (76%) (Table 1) Occupation wise agricultural workers were on top of the list (48%) followed by house wives (22.6%) and labours (16. %) (Table 2). It was observed in our study that highest number of patients consumed Dichlorvos (50.6%), followed by Methyl parathion (24%), the least consumed compound was Others (8%). (Table 3) The commonest motive of poisoning was suicidal in both males (57.3%) and females (42.6%), followed by accidental (14.3%). Homicidal poisoning was observed in 3 (4%) in males and females observed in 1 (1.33%) cases only (Table 4). Financial problem was one of the commonest reasons of poisoning (57.3%). The mortality rate in our study was 13.44%; it was fairly low because the majority of patients reached our hospital well within the fatal period. Respiratory failure was the leading cause of death in our study, followed by multi-organ failure. Acute complications were noted very frequently and were related to morbidity and mortality.

Discussion

Acute Organophosphorus compound poisoning is one of the commonest cause of acute poisoning in Vijayawada with high mortality, particularly among the agricultural workers. The probable cause of high mortality are depending on the variety of factors such as easy availability of the poison, large group of agricultural population, socioeconomic status of the population and stressful life, particularly of youth. Incidence of cases are majorly seen in male (55.16%) and they were in age group of 21 to 30 years (43.81%); similar observations were noted in other studies. 5

In our study among the Organophosphorus compounds, Dichlorvos was the most commonly consumed Poison (50.6%), although Diazinon was the most commonly used compound in another study as reported by Singh et al. In present study the most common motive of poisoning was with a Suicidal intention and the higher number of victims were agricultural workers (51.07%), residing specifically in rural areas. Studies suggest that Organophosphorus compound as an insecticides, pesticides and fungicides was more in rural areas than urban especially pesticide poisoning was responsible for 30% of the global fatalities, in addition to majority of suicide emergency care admissions in developing countries.6, 7, 8

Thungs et al also reported incidence of death (6.3%) to be higher in participants having taken >30ml compound than those with <30ml intake (2.7%) during acute OP poisoning episode.9

One more study showed that 75% of poisonings occur among economically weaker sections, which mainly reside in rural areas. Accidental poisoning in our study was mainly seen in children due to accidental ingestion and in adults due to accidental exposure.10, 11

In our study the mortality rate was 17.3%, which was is quite low because the majority of the victims received treatment in the EMS 108 ambulance which provides primary care treatment to patient within half an hour, hence the survival rate was higher in our study.

Similarly, one more study conducted in Eastern Ethiopia, identified in the community level of awareness is very low regarding pesticide use. 12, 13

Zaheer et al., found that most people believe that poison terminates life with minimal suffering. 14, 15

Most commonly used insecticides for poisoning were Methyl Parathion and Dichlorovos which is part of OP poisoning and this is consistent with other studies carried out in Nepal. 16, 17, 18

Poisoning due to inhalation cases are less when compared with oral intake which is a major intake of OP Poisoning similar to our study. 19

It has been observed that incidence of death was found to be significantly more in those patients in whom a greater time interval had elapsed between consumption of the poison and hospitalization.

Conclusion

This Prospective analysis of organophosphorus poisoning is one of the most common poisonings in and around the rural areas of Vijayawada, predominantly in the young population with a male predominance, belonging to low socioeconomic class. The commonest motive of poisoning was suicidal. Lack of education, poverty, cheap and readily easy availability of the Organophosphorus compounds, unemployment and stressful life were the common reasons behind the reason of poisoning. Hence education amongst the agricultural workers and youth about the harmful and deleterious effects of Organophosphorus compounds and up gradation of the primary health centre facilities to render immediate management of Similarly strict implementation of the pesticide act and involving a new policy by the government to educate the public and youth in large about the dangerous, life threatening effects of Organophosphorus compounds could help amelerioating the harmful effects of such poisoning.

Recommendations

Implement public health education programs about the dangers of OP compounds, strengthen mental health services to address underlying causes of intentional poisoning.

Conduct further research to monitor the long-term trends and effectiveness of intervention strategies.

Ethical Approval

The study was approved by the Institutional Ethics Committee

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

M Darren CK Roberts Managing acute Organophosphorus pesticide poisoningJ Indian Acad Foren Med2007334462963

2 

ST Kavya SV Chandana R Madhumati Clinical Profile of Patients with Organophosphorus poisoning in an intensive care unit in a tertiary hospitalInt J Clin Cases Invest201243314

3 

SB Agarwal Acute Organophosphorus poisoningEnviron Res1993626370

4 

H Prashant P Sneha Organophosphorus poisoning: study of evaluation of clinically relevant indicatorsInt J Adv Med2022910102730

5 

F Mancini L Janice O Malley Reducing incidence of acute pesticide poisoning by educating farmers on integrated pest management in South IndiaInt J Occup Environ Health200915214351

6 

C Dharmani K Jaga Epidemiology of acute organophosphate poisoning in hospital emergency room patientsRev Environ Health200520321547

7 

G Thungs KG Sam K Khera S Pandey SV Sagar Evaluation of organophosphorus poisoning cases in a tertiary care hospitalJ Tox Env Health Sci201025739

8 

JD Beard Pesticide exposure and depression among male private pesticide applicators in the agricultural health studyEnviron. Health Perspect2014122998491

9 

SB Marahatta J Singh R Shrestha R Koju Poisoning cases attending emergency department in Dhulikhel Hospital- Kathmandu University Teaching HospitalKathmandu Univ Med J20097261528

10 

MB Mood K Shirazi Organophosphate side effectsIranian J Pharma Res200627987

11 

S Murat G Muhammed Intensive care management of organophosphate insecticide poisoningCrit Care2001542116

12 

B Tadesse H Kibret H Heluf S Mesfin Y Alemu Pattern and outcome of acute organophosphate poisoning at health facilities of Harari Region, Eastern EthiopiaSAGE Open Med20091110710746PMCID

13 

AG Derso GG Dagnew Exposure and health risk assessment of farmers to DDT during khat production in chiro Woreda, West Hararghe zone EthiopiaWorld J Agric Res2019712935

14 

GM Adinew AB Asrie EM Birru Pattern of acute organophosphorus poisoning at University of Gondar Teaching Hospital, Northwest EthiopiaBMC Res Notes2017101149

15 

MS Zaheer M Aslam V Gupta V Sharma SA Khan Profle of poisoning cases at a north indian tertiary care hospitalHealth Popul Perspect Issues200932417683

16 

J Gargi Current trend of poisoning-A hospital profileJ Indian Med Assoc2006104294

17 

D Gunnell M Eddleston M R Phillips F Konradsen The global distribution of fatal pesticide self-poisoning: systematic reviewBMC Public Health20077357

18 

KK Ka MK Nepal SR Sharma RP Pokharel Poisoning cases at T.U. Teaching HospitalJ Inst Med198911297301

19 

BK Suvedi A retrospective study of poisoning cases at Bir Hospital, NepalJ Inst Med1990121296302



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

Article type

Original Article


Article page

97-100


Authors Details

N. Devchand, Ande Krishnajaneyulu, Muchukota Babu, MV Muralidhar, Muchukota Sushma


Article History

Received : 10-07-2024

Accepted : 27-08-2024


Article Metrics


View Article As

 


Downlaod Files